I want to first clarify that this is not a knee jerk reaction after watching India’s dramatic collapse yesterday. India decided to bat first on a pitch with lots of moisture and conditions which were perfect for the pacers. I understand their thinking behind but the execution was poor. India over the past 2 years have been making good cricket pitches where they have been excelling but everyone knows that the batting is far from settled. Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli have not been scoring runs and India have been largely relying on Jaiswal, Pant and the lower order even at home.

Yesterday’s call was even more baffling considering the only conditions the New Zealand bowling can be successful in India was the one they bowled in yesterday. The lack of experience in the batting showed when none of the batters knew how to handle the situation. They not only went into their shell but also played shots which were implausible in such conditions. When New Zealand came into bat, the pitch eased out and our pacers were under tremendous pressure to deliver and failed to pick any wickets with the new ball. The visitors though would not be complaining as they are sitting pretty with 134 runs lead with 7 wickets still intact.

Gautam Gambhir & Rohit Sharma are taking risks to win Test matches and to make to another WTC finals but the decisions need to be made based on the strength’s of team in mind. It is all good when these things come of but when it doesn’t it looks ugly. The fact that the team who has 18 straight home series wins got bowled out for 46 at home is pretty humiliating. Indian batting line up in such conditions even when Pujara and Rahane were in the middle order struggled which is the prime reason for the team to not win a series in England, New Zealand or in South Africa over the past decade. This Indian batting though with out of form Rohit and Virat was always going to be recipe for disaster. While the team management would have expected troubles even they wouldn’t have anticipated what unfolded on day 1.

The young batters who have predominantly played at home panicked when runs weren’t coming and did not know how to handle such disciplined bowling. The New Zealand bowling was completely at home with conditions resembling of their home and the home team had no answers. Now that the visitors have taken such big lead already they are in a great situation to hand a rare home defeat to India. The Indian team management had only themselves to blame as they thought way ahead into the game rather than looking at the conditions at hand. This also comes with the over confidence of thinking they are invincible at home. New Zealand who were coming to India after trial by spin in Sri Lanka wouldn’t have been able to believe their luck when India gave their bowlers the best conditions to bowl in.

India now have no other option other than hoping that they can bowl the Kiwis out soon and Day 3 and bat better in the second innings. Things do not look for the home team and unless the weather intervenes the chances of saving the game looks bleak. The team management need to think about winning games but also need to make decisions based on the conditions they are playing in. Rohit got the toss completely wrong and the horrible execution by the batters did not help either. I just hope that some lessons are learnt and the team goes forward with better planning in the future. This has also raised concerns about the batting line up for the next 2 Tests and also the Border Gavaskar Trophy later this year. I love Rohit and Virat but I think their time in Tests are coming to an end and I hope the players themselves along with the management understand the same.